Rehab Center Finds Limits to Cost Cutting
by Paulette Thomas
The Problem: Managed care slashes the revenue
of a nonprofit rehabilitation center causing it to fall into
disarray.
The Caron Foundation, a rehab stay for drug or alcohol addition,
located in several beautiful old buildings on the green hills
near Reading, Pa and dating back to the middle of last century
can no longer offer 28 day treatments. The insurance rate
spikes of the 1990's has created a new reality, lower reimbursements
for fewer treatments at shorter durations.
Douglas Tieman was the number 2 executive at Hazelden, a
rehab center in Center City, Minn., when he received a call
from a recruiter about taking over at Caron. It seems that
Caron was $5 million in debt, and revenues had dropped by
half to $10 million. Previous managers had tried to solve
the problem by cutting costs and reducing the staff from 450
to 200. As a result morale was very low.
Mr. Tieman had always wanted to run his own facility so he
agreed to take over. On his arrival he found the situation
to be much worse than expected with the beautiful buildings
full of faulty plumbing as well as ancient heating and information
systems. Also, there were many money losing programs and now
in 1995, Caron was a year from closure.
The Solution
Cost cutting measures had gone too far. Instead Mr. Tieman
focused on making better use of the funds available and seeking
new sources of it.
Initially, he met with all of the 200 employees in small
groups to hear their concerns. He praised their efforts, and
told them exactly where things stood as well as what to expect
including bonuses for measurable good results. These meetings
continued monthly.
He eliminated cash draining programs. One such program for
drunken driving has a local county pay $32 a day to cover
a Caron stay with meals and therapy. He kept other programs
with zero reimbursement, including one that charges $1,600
a week per person for family members of addicts. It's so successful
that participants pay out of pocket.
Other simple changes also added to the bottom line. The staff
to patient ratio was tightened and a big savings was gained
from refinancing Caron's debt from a rate of 10% down to 3%.
Most important, Mr. Tieman strengthened Caron's ties to the
philanthropic community. He took a 3 year comeback plan to
wealthy alumnus of the center and sought a donor to cover
the first year's shortfall of $392,000. The donor eventually
gave $500,000 of the $1.3 million raised that first year.
Armed with that backing and better financial results, other
donors signed up. Last year the funds hit $6.3 million. Now,
the debt is zero and patient satisfaction is above 90%.
The Lesson
Drastic cutbacks only go so far. How carefully funds are
put to use and finding new sources of revenue set the course.
|