Ready for the start-up game? Try these tough questions
BY SHAWN NEIDORF
Mercury News
Every week, I get calls and e-mails from entrepreneurs with
questions like, how do I find the right VC to back my company?
Or how do I set a valuation for my company? Or what do I need
to do to get started?
I'm a journalist, not a business adviser, so I don't recommend
one venture firm over another, nor do I help set dollar figures
or write business plans.
But I have pointed people to resources that could help them
make their own decisions, and I am compiling them here. I've
never been a venture capitalist or an entrepreneur, and I
don't have an MBA. My advice is based on several years of
reporting on VC and my own idea of what I would do if I were
going to start a company.
The first thing I'd do is ask myself some tough questions:
1. Could a $500 million-plus company be built around my idea
within a few years? Smaller ambitions will not attract VCs'
attention and those with more local or niched proposals will
have to look elsewhere for money.
2. Who would my customers be? Would my product or service
solve a sizable problem for them? Would they pay for it? VCs
favor a company that fixes big problems over one that makes
mild to moderate improvements in an already working system
because it's easier to sell solutions than improvements.
3. How many competitors are there, and how well established
are they? Can I really beat them? Try to avoid playing the
mind game of assuming that companies using another approach
to tackle the same issue aren't competitors just because their
methods are different. The VCs -- and potential customers
-- will see right through it.
4. Do I have the temperament and experience to be an entrepreneur?
Am I comfortable taking on the risks and demands? Talk to
other entrepreneurs -- including those whose companies have
failed -- to get a clear sense of what it could be like.
5. Am I willing to give up, over time, majority ownership
in my company to get the money and assistance venture capitalists
provide? Can I accept that I might not be CEO, at least not
for very long?
If your answers to these questions lead you to believe that
seeking venture capital is the right thing to do, keep reading.
You're going to need a business plan, preferably one that
is coherently written. Perhaps even more important, you need
a sharply written executive summary, because it will be read
far more often than your business plan. Right up at the top,
you must have a sentence that clearly spells out what your
company will do or make and for whom.
Thumb through your address book to figure what lawyers, accountants,
consultants, headhunters and successful entrepreneurs you
already know who could help you hone your plan and then make
introductions to appropriate venture capitalists. Keep in
mind that few business plans that flow in over the venture
firms' transoms without introductions get funded.
If you want to look on your own for VCs, you could consult
directories such as Pratt's Guide to Venture Capital Sources
or Galante's Venture Capital & Private Equity Directory,
keeping in mind that the data -- especially regarding what
types of companies each firm backs -- tends to be very broad
and sometimes out of date.
You want to pitch your plan to firms with interest and experience
in your field, but you do not want to display your guts to
a firm backing a competitor. Research the portfolios of venture
firms you would consider approaching. Check their Web sites
and filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission to
learn about their holdings.
Read articles in newspapers and magazines, including the
PricewaterhouseCoopers/Mercury News' quarterly venture surveys
that list each local company that got funding and from whom.
But keep in mind that stealth companies, those that are keeping
their existence a secret, probably will not be listed on Web
sites, surveys or in SEC filings until they're registering
for an IPO.
Talk to entrepreneurs backed by firms you're considering.
Good venture firms will want you to do this. You might also
want to go down to the courthouse to find out if any entrepreneurs
have sued the VCs you are considering and, if so, why.
So how many venture firms should you go after? I'd start
with a handful. You do not want to be shopping your idea up
and down Sand Hill Road, but you probably will want to work
with more than one firm at a time to keep the fundraising
process from dragging on too long.
When it comes to setting a valuation for your company, of
course you'll look at similar companies in the public market
for comparison, discounting your own valuation in light of
your company's stage of development. You also will want to
know what kind of valuations other start-ups in your sector
are getting, though that data can be hard to come by, given
its sensitivity.
Also, you might want to call Venture One of San Francisco
or Venture Economics of Newark, N.J., both of which collect
and sell data about venture capital financings. See their
Web sites for more information (www.ventureone.com; www.venture
economics.com).
Good luck!
|